Il Fantasma dell'Opera
in the Media

July 13, 1998: Kate sent me the following information: "You might be interested to know that "Shivers" has an article about "Phantom." Though the photos used are the same as on Dario Argento's site, the interview with Argento is informative. According to the article, Julian Sands was the second choice to play Erik after John Malkovich who had originally considered the part. According to the article, Argento was extremely happy with Sands' performance and enthusiasm (my summary, not a direct quote.)
If you can't find a copy of the magazine, their US address is: Shivers, Visual Imagination Limited, PO Box 156, Manorville, NY 11949, Tel: (818)980-1727, E-mail: vismagus@earthlink.net. For the E-mail address, it asks you to please mention Shivers. The issue with the Phantom article is #54." Thanks, Kate!

Fantasma and Director

More information on Phantom from site visitor (I'm going to start calling him our "European correspondant"!) David M. (July 1, 1998): "According to the French magazine Cahiers du Cinema, the first 20 minutes of the film were shown at the Italian pavilion at the Cannes Film Festival in May. The test screening was such a success that the film is now an Official Selection at the Venice Film Festival this autumn. So Julian may be in for a MAJOR career resurrection! (About time, too.) Of course, Cahiers did not mention him once. It's a snooty magazine, run by up-their-arse French intellectuals who still cling to the 60's auteur theory - where the only person who EXISTS is the director. Still, they did give some interesting background info on the film. Believe it or not, Dario Argento has been trying to get this project off the ground for the past 20 years. He wanted to set the film in St. Petersburg in 1905, just before the first (abortive) Russian Revolution. The script is far more than standard slasher material. It's co-written by Gerard Brach, a French screenwriter who worked on many of Roman Polanski's best films. They've added a lot of bizarre dream sequences and - I assume - political elements. Also, because Argento is a great opera fan (me too!) there will be music by Georges Bizet, Jacques Offenbach, Jules Massenet as well as an original music score by Ennio Morricone. (He also did the music for Husbands and Lovers.) It sounds far more promising than the OTHER 'Phantom' project - a film version of Andrew Lloyd Webber's schlock musical, set to star Antonio Banderas. (Sorry, I heard enough of HIS singing in Evita!)." -- Thanks again, David!

NewTranslation of the new interview with Dario Argento on Il Fantasma dell'Opera:

(This was translated via AltaVista's computerized translation option, and while I fleshed out some of the rough or obviously inaccurate translations, some of it was rather mystifying when it got turned into English. If you can decipher some of the rougher areas, please let me know.)

We meet the director on the set of " Il Fantasma dell'Opera " of which he is concluding the filming.
" It is my first story of love... "
(article edited by Pia Maria Fusco, the Republic - Sunday 22 March 1998)

Galleries, caverns, underground passages, an extraordinary maze that is opened to whim in wonderful " halls " in which stalactites and stalagmites furnishings and fantastic sculptures are combined, on which the reflected light of streams and small lakes formed for the " Dark Man " films, an underground river that tenaciously digs bizzarrly covered in the heart of the mountain. They are the Coves of Pertosa, 70 kilometers from Salerno, a tourist place that Dario Argento has transformed in the basements of the Opéra of Paris, or moreover the dwelling of the most famous phantom of literature and the cinema, Il Fantasma dell'Opera, destined "monstrous" creature living in the dark, legacy to the external world from the music that arrives to it from the stage. Published in 1911, set in the second half of the 800's, the novel of Gaston Leroux is beloved to the cinema. Between the seven versions most notable, in 1925 of Julian with Lon Chaney, that one of Lubin of the ' 43 with Claude Rains, and " the fastasma of the stage " of Brian De Palma in ' 74. It is in Argento's version, that one, that he has set the Opéra in the lyric theatre of Budapest.

Pertosa (Salerno) - For Dario Argento "Il Fantasma dell'Opera" is " a dark story of love ", but the true surprise is that, for the first time in his career, he declares the intention to make a " political " film. The story is set in 1877, less than 30 years after the publication of The Manifest of Marx and Engels, and the tie in is easy: A phantom goes around Europe... "my" phantom is " the new " man, lover of music and the stolen books in the library of the Opéra, who with his way of thinking succeeds in seducing Christine, the young singer. But Beauty in the historical moment is the Epoque, after a century of revolutions and of dead women, people wanted to divert, to eat, to dance, only to make love, to laugh, and a man who recalls culture, the respect of the differences and the human values is seen like an annoying disturbance, to be eliminated ".

REPUBLIC: But in imaginary filmmaking the phantom is a physically repellent man...

Argento: The cinema has embroidered a lot on the novel of Leroux, the most faithful film has been that one with Lon Chaney of ' 25, the best one. I am coming from the novel, also in the logistics. The Coves of Pertosa are perfect, I had need of basements with a lake, the water that separates him from the world strengthens the isolation of the character. I have only made two great "betrayals": I have removed the mask of the phantom and have filled up the empty bits of the text. Leroux for example is very vague about the past of the man, from where he came, who has raised him. "Because of fortuitous circumstances, a mysterious alliance has been born between the abandoned child and the inhabitants of the darknesses...", writes Leroux. In my film the baby is saved by rats, it is the rats that raise it. And I have recovered all the ironic parts that were in Leroux and that the cinema has sacrificed. The reactions of the external world to the phantom are grotesque, are grotesque in the character of the lyric singer - Nadia Rinaldi - that the phantom wants to eliminate for love of Christine, because she is to have the Daisy role in Faust.

REPUBLIC: With the political film definition it wants to say that there is also a resentment for the present time?

Argento: Why not? We do not live a period of total disengagement? In the film there is also the character of a Communist that, after battered for his ideals, has been transformed into one that only thinks of the next monies and what happened to one personally.

REPUBLIC: The script is written by Gerard Brach. What has he contributed to it?

Argento: Brach has been passionate about the history of this man who has never left the theatre, because also he suffers from the strongest kind of progressive agoraphobia. At this point he does not only not exit his home, but he is difficult to decoy from his room, where he lives safe between the books. And therefore he very well knew the phobia of the phantom.

REPUBLIC: It says that Christine is enamoured of the phantom. But Julian Sands who plays him, with long unkempt hair, a scar on the cheekbone, the tenebrous appearance of skin and the spectral whiteness, is surely not a desirable man... (SITEMISTRESS' NOTE: we know better about him in real life, but Julian manages to look quite startling in the Phantom's guise...)

Argento: Frightening enough, but the sections (feelings?) are noble and kind. Christine is chaste, ingenuous, loves the young baron Raoul, who is beautiful, elegant, the corteggia with grace. But the speeches of the phantom, the force of his passion and the dedication without reserve with which the protege to the end fascinates him, and as he is not a true phantom but a man in flesh and bones, making love with mutual satisfaction. The problem is that it seems impossible to love two men at the same time. Young, ingenuous, she still does not know that these things happen... She before that time had one love history.

REPUBLIC: How much time will it be next to a film from Leroux?

Argento: At least twenty years. I wanted to film in Moscow, and it appealed to one connection with Rasputin, a black and diabolic spirit, politically meaningful. I would have had to turn to the Bolscioi, inasmuch as for years the Opéra is impractical, has become a museum. But then too many complications are fate and the plan is jumped. Il Fantasma dell'Opera is one of those films that they have marked to me, rather than has pushed to me towards the cinema. Remember still that I saw with my brother in a room to the open, when we were in vacation on the Dolomiti, the version with Claude Rains.

REPUBLIC: After many monsters and fear, after much violence on the screen and in tv, then what in the cinema of the fear is new?

Argento: By now it is difficult to invent something new that astonishes the public. Now it is the moment to return to another type of restlessness, to the " monster " within us, to the callback of the psychological identification. It is not a coincidence that Stephen King has returned to writing thrillers and that my great friend George Romero, that I have met magically in Budapest in means of the fog, is preparing one new version from " the crow " of Poe. A good militant catholic, Romero is one species of missionary of the dark part of us. In " Il Fantasma dell'Opera ", beyond that from the uneasiness that provokes the presence of the " various one ", there are classical elements of fear. The phantom that arranges several troubles, can be very cruel, when it feels hostility and hatred. Cruel like animals, for necessary defense. He, that has seen in the basements of the Opéra the ferocity with which massacred the Communist, is sentenced to the free cruelty of the men.

REPUBLIC: There are many animals?

Argento: Bats, scorpions, snakes, scarafaggi, worms. And rats naturally, many rats. There is a sequence in which Julian Sands is covered to the waist with 400 rats. All real, no special effect. In order not to succumb to the panic, he has used the technique of the Yoga concentration. I am not afraid of rats.

REPUBLIC: There is something that you do fear?

Argento: Women. Some of them I have had have made me indeed fear, if I rethink I still feel the thrills. It is not a case that never is not married me, my daughters say that they have become a monaco.


The actress in the third film with her father: that challenge of a film in costume

Pertosa (Salerno) - " I was scared, I did not feel myself up to the role", says Asia Argento. "And then in the beginning Christine was unpleasant, one little girl vitiated, virgin and chaste, one species of " little shit " posh girl, all withholding. Then, when the phantom seduces her, she lets go, free, and being with him in the basements she becomes also disgusting, liking the spiders, the rats and all the things that before displeased her ". According to Asia Argento, Christine is " the first romantic heroine that yields to the feelings and does not know how to handle them. Completeness between two loves is found. One with Raoul, he is tender, friendly, also brotherly, and one with the phantom, that is sweeping, passionate but also uneven, in the sense that he is adult, picked, illuminated, could be also her father. And as she does not know how to decide between the two, leaves that to the phantom to decide for her". Though her co-stars, Julian Sands and Andrea Di Stefano (the prince of Homburg) have already appeared in period films, for Asia Argento a role in costume is unusual. " And it is a beautiful challenge, someone also has written that I should not be set to roles in costume. But it is not true that the costume does not have importance, it is important that I " feel " the personage, and this, after the first days of filming, has happened. When we turn I feel it arrive, like it had its own life. I had never perceived such a feeling, perhaps why up to now in the girls who I have played there was always similarity, while Christine is much different from me".
It is the third film of Asia Argento with her father, " but it is the first the time that I see my father so inspired and participating. He usually does not speak very much with the actors, but in the preparation of " Il Fantasma dell'Opera " has spoken much, has asked me what I thought, how I saw Christine, we have discussed. And during the previous filming he knew what he wanted, he decided, instead now he consults, he is to feel to us, he explains. Perhaps it is sincere that this is the film that he really has dreamed to make ". Daughter of art, actress from childhood, Asia retains one curiosity, tender insecurity. " I tend to star badly if they say negative things to me. I would not want to be so fragile, but my acting always depends on what people say to me ", telling the problem of the first days of filming " The New Rose Hotel" with Abel Ferrara, in which I have participated of recent in America. " Abel leaves the actors total freedom, indeed expects it, wants that everyone moves as it seems to them, he says that it tries to you with the taken machine from, the actor must ignore. The first days I was a lot preoccupied, but when I have understood the game, they are very amusing to me".

Well, I had a few weeks to get used to my translation of the article, and then I discovered that there are always going to be differences when people translate things. I've signed up for the Dario Argento mailing list to make sure we have the latest and most inside information, and one of the list-members just posted his own version of the article, which, while it flows a lot better, doesn't mesh with what I had in a few places. So, read both, and take what you like from them:

Sitting in the box number 5, the Phantom is listening to the young Christine who warbles Opera airs on stage. He’s a beautiful man, his long blonde hair on his suffering melancholic face. Predictably, it’s love at first sight and the passion for each other will lead them to perdition.

At last, after a thirty year career, with thirteen deliriously nightmarish films which brought him love and hate equally, Dario Argento had his mind made up and accepted the challenge of "The Phantom of the Opera", the black classic romantic melodrama (written by Gaston Leroux) that is set in the 19th century Paris, upon which several movies were based, from the classic silent film by Rupert Julian to the rock version by Brian De Palma (not to mention the musical by Andrew Lloyd Webber). And right away the "Italian Maestro of Horror" takes us by surprise: for his film, he chose a different approach; unlike the novel, both the skull and the mask (which hides pitifully the monstrous features of the phantom) are absent. No red eyes popping out of their sockets: "Erik is neither deformed nor disfigured. It’s his soul which is damned, it’s his heart which is black, mean and cruel."

In Cinecittà, where he’s now editing the film together, Argento, his wizard eyes blazing, his face hollow, says: "In comparison with the terrific first edition (starring Lon Chaney), which was shot at the Paris Opera House before the latter was designated National Monument, all the others were very free adaptations. By contrast, my film is very faithful to the original book, which is a very precise account of the Theatre of that period, filled with humour, passion and horror.

The plot. In the underneath of the Opera House, which plunges into tunnels and passages down to a subterranean lake, lives Erik, a damned soul who’s as thirsty for blood as a vampire is and, like Don Juan, he’s master of the art of seduction. Just like Faust, he’s doomed to perdition, fated to lose both his soul and his beloved. He’s the Phantom, a great musician who falls in love with a small soprano, Christine Daae, sensual and innocent at the same time, played by the intensely gorgeous Asia Argento, the third film directed by her father.After Erik gets rid of the prima donna, Carlotta, a plump boastful Nadia Rinaldi, Christine is called to replace her and under the Phantom’s spell she gives a remarkable performance.

By eliminating the monstrous aspect, Mr. Argento was able to stress the seducing character of the protagonist. The director says: "Christine is suddenly overwhelmed by the intensity of her passion and, since my film casts light on was concealed in the original novel, there are explicit sex scenes. Julian and Asia make a fine couple. But soon Christine sees the cruel spiteful nature of Erik and prefers the viscount Raoul de Chagny (Andrea Di Stefano), who’s stupid all right, but much more reassuring.

Mr. Argento had been thinking about this movie for long time: "Yes, I was beginning to get the idea when I was making Suspira, in the late 70’s, when I watched again the film with Lon Chaney, which is very impressive. The original project was to shoot the film in Moscow, at the Bolscioi Theatre, but since the Soviets only had a keen interest in realistic movies, they let the project drop." After several attempts, this project finally came to light. The film was shot at Budapest and Cinecittà, and it cost a lot of money: ten million dollars. "I had been studying the period of the novel for a long time. I lived in Paris for a year, watching all the European movies set in the 19th century, listening to the music of that century: Offenbach, Gounoud, Massenet, Bizet. Music is of central importance in the film (but music has always been of central importance in my production). I also saw a George de La Tour exhibition and his paintings, in which Rembrandt and Caravaggio left their stylistic mark, exerted their influence on the film, especially because of their use of light (of torches and candles) and dark. Also Degas is an important part of the atmosphere".

The script was written by Argento and Gerard Brach, a Parisian agoraphobic follower of Surrealism, who had previously worked even with Roman Polanski. "It seemed to me that an agoraphobic was the ideal companion to describe a character who lives in the bowels of a theatre".

Argento had been working side by side with Brach for six months and eventually, says Argento: "I got agoraphobic too. There is a saying in Italy that "He that dwells next door to a cripple will learn to halt". Well, it’s the gospel truth."

The period in which the novel is set is a relatively quiet time after many social and political ferments. Dario says: "It’s the "belle epoque", an era of gaiety, elegance and fashionable balls and restaurants, though it was still an era plagued by uncertainties.

Offenbach, who’s a great underrated figure, whose production has always been wrongly considered to be as "easy", is typical of that time: in his "Orpheus", even the sad melancholy death is sung of with a light touch.

While in the Opera House life is celebrated with music and dancing, in the dim bowels of the theatre, plunged into darkness, the Phantom is free to wander. He can be seen as the new man, the man who was born in that period, the man who relates to men and animals differently, whose spartan life, simple and strict, with no luxuries, is the antithesis of the "Belle Epoque". His cruelty is part of his modernity. The Phantom could also be interpreted as a follower of Marxism, which heavily mined all the established certainties. In a way, this film is my first political film".

In the first shot of the film, a mother cries in fright in the pouring rain in the usual and typical traditional melodrama fashion. A new-born baby is abandoned in a basket, swept down into a subterranean passage by the current and taken in custody of rats, which are not seen as nasty animals carrying terrible diseases, but as nice companions of Erik. They are almost brothers to him. Rats are the real protagonists of the movie. Four hundred rats were transported from Rome to Budapest with a lorry.

According to Argento,, rats are "sweet clever animals. The problem is that they stink terribly. And there’s nothing you can do to get rid of the revolting smell, since the effect on your nose remains for a long time. Special nose-brushes, used for cleaning our nostrils, were provided for the crew. Julian Sands was able to overcome his fear of rats only by means of transcendental meditation. As for me, rats don’t scare me."

Argento admits this was his hardest film to date: "It was very difficult to shoot in those Hungarian caves. We were filming about three kilometres under the ground, at night, with a freezing cold and water dripping down the walls. There was even danger of getting lost, since it was a real labyrinth down there. And we couldn’t defecate nor urinate because the air in those caves is healthy, very good for the people with lung diseases. Therefore the place must remain aseptic. On the first day they raised hell when someone went for a pee and kicked us out for a week. Then I said I’d vouch for the troupe and, indeed, from that time on I had to check on everybody. Besides, since the place was plunged into darkness, we lost several animals: spiders, snakes, rats, worms...

The film is also filled with sophisticated special effects which in a number of cases were obtained with mechanic devices - the scene where a chandelier falls off, crashing down onto the audience for example, or the shot in which Carlotta is crushed to death by a falling pillar.

Argento reveals that "The Phantom of the Opera" is a film with much gore because, romantic and passionate as it is, "the story is very cruel. Ever since I was a child, as an avid reader of Edgar Allan Poe, I’ve always been fascinated by ‘the dark side of life’, which became an obsessive subject of narration. The problem is that censors all over the world think that my films are true stories. They don’t seem to realise that a director who makes a film on a serial killer is not necessarily a murderer". In fact, as Argento was an affectionate son (he had been working side by side with his father for a long while, and he’s still working with his brother), so he’s an affectionate father. "Asia is a very close friend of mine. She’s always been, since she was a small child" he says.

"The Phantom of the Opera" will be released next November together with the CD by Ennio Morricone, who scored the movie. The film will be given at the Venice Festival in the "events" section. "After so many years, it’s the first time I’ve been invited. I must resist the urge to say no" he concludes wryly.

Hungry for those images? Click Here.


Home | Biography | Career News | Links | Images | Filmography | Phantom
Multimedia | Poll | Quiz | Sitemistress' Office | NEWS